
Treating Knee Pain in Your Athlete
With the generous support of Hoag Orthopedic Institute, IPSF is committed to keeping Irvine’s high school athletes safe and healthy by providing athletic trainers at each of the district’s five comprehensive high schools. These trainers play a crucial role in preventing injuries, assessing risk factors, delivering targeted treatment and rehabilitation, and addressing health concerns linked to athletic performance—such as managing concussion risks. One of the most common issues they encounter is knee pain, affecting many student-athletes.
To shed light on this, we spoke with Dr. Taylor Dunphy, an orthopedic surgeon from HOI, to discuss the common causes of knee pain and effective approaches for treatment.
Q: What are the most common causes for knee pain?
A: Knee tears can occur in the meniscus, ligaments and tendons surrounding the knee. These are usually due to trauma, falls or sports. The pain tends to be sudden onset and sharp in nature.
Meniscus tears usually result in mild swelling, sharp pain at the sides or back of the knee. Meniscus pain is usually aggravated by squatting and twisting type maneuvers. Meniscus tears can largely be treated conservatively with NSAIDs, steroid injections, and physical therapy. In younger, active individuals, or those with a “locked” knee, surgery may be required.
Ligament tears, such as ACL, MCL, LCL, or PCL tears result in sharp pain, swelling and feelings of instability. MCL, LCL, and PCL tears can usually be treated without surgery with bracing and physical therapy. While ACL tears in young, athletic individuals often require surgery, tendon tears of the patellar, and quadriceps tendons usually result from a fall or a quick explosive movement—like jumping. Tendon tears can result in pain, loss of strength, and difficulty extending the leg. Partial tears can be treated with physical therapy, icing and NSAIDS, while full tears likely will need surgery.
Knee tendonitis is typically caused by overuse injuries, commonly found in athletes and runners. Tendonitis can affect the hamstrings, quadriceps and patellar tendons. This pain is usually achy in nature gets worse with activity. While not debilitating, tendonitis can lead to more chronic pain. It is largely treated without surgery and will respond to NSAIDs and physical therapy.
Q: What advice do you have for athletes experiencing knee pain?
A: If the pain is sudden onset and from trauma resulting in limitations in strength, range of motion or sensations of instability, the athlete should ice immediately, apply a compressive sleeve or wrap, take an NSAID (if safe) and seek an urgent evaluation by an orthopedic surgeon.
If your athlete has chronic knee pain, I recommend taking Tylenol or NSAIDs, ice, using a compression sleeve, and trying some home exercises. If symptoms don’t improve within 6 weeks, I would recommend a consultation with an orthopedic surgeon , who will likely order imaging and recommend physical therapy.
About Dr. Dunphy

Dr. Taylor R. Dunphy is an orthopedic surgeon who is fellowship-trained in Sports Medicine. He has a passion for treating athletes of all ages and has served as a team physician for the University of Southern California, where he helped care for the Trojans’ football, basketball, soccer, volleyball, lacrosse, and track teams. Dr. Dunphy is committed to providing the highest quality patient care, and believes medicine is best performed through a collective, patient-centric approach. He focuses on creating individualized programs that are optimized to achieve the best results for each patient, with surgery oftentimes not being the first approach.